![]() Many worry that in order for technology to work without teachers, children need to be better behaved and teach each other. How will learning difficulties of students with disabilities be reflected in the assessments? Students with autism and gifted students, for example, might start out with problematic behavior in school, but make great gains.Ĭhildren experiencing trauma, or problems that cause them difficulties in school, need counselors, school psychologists, and social workers to address their needs. SEL and students with disabilities and gifted students. How much self-control is too much?Is developmental age considered? Certain behaviors are normal for young children. SEL involves an emphasis on self-control. ![]() There was a reason schools kept a student’s record in a locked filing cabinet. What happens if the student has a bad year? What if their parents divorce in 5th grade and they have problems then, but they’ve adjusted by 8th grade? Will their behavior from 5th grade haunt them forever? Where will that information be when the student applies for college? Social Skills Improvement System Rating Scales.Social-Emotional Assets and Resilience Scale (SEARS).Devereux Early Childhood Assessment, Second Edition (For PreK).Here’s a list from Edutopia of some of the assessments: Why do all children require such serious assessment? Most children come to school ready to learn and without major behavioral problems. The assessments seem designed for school psychologists for when children have difficulties in school. What right do adults have to scrutinize a child’s thoughts and feelings for data? These aren’t merely interest inventories. SEL assessments for parents, children, and teachers ask personal questions. Both religious and non-religious parents often resent it.Įven Angela Duckworth, the “grit” queen, grew concernedabout measuring character traits, calling it a “bad idea.” SEL involves grit, soft skills, or character education.Ĭharacter education has always been controversial. If SEL seems like character education it’s because it is. recognize how others have contributed to their achievement,.record their emotional behavior changes as they transition throughout the day,.Here’s a sampling of what children are to do: But forcing children to reflect so much on their actions, thoughts, and feelings is obsessive. SEL standards involve too much introspection for children.Īs part of the Every Student Succeeds Act, the Illinois SEL Standardshave been praised for being the first state SEL standards. Where’s the research? The reliance of support is on a 2011 Meta-analysis of eight studies showing students do better academically with SEL activities, but there’s nothing to support the pervasive dominance of SEL assessment in schools. “Core” is used often, because SEL is connected to Common Core. There’s a mish-mash of psycho-social, neuroscience talk, and programs are not always well-explained to parents, or well-understood. SEL is ill-defined, unproven and still connected to Common Core. Here are the concerns about SEL in general. It’s easy to see how one can be sucked into the nice activities for children, without realizing what this organization is truly advocating. One teacher told me they are “like stalkers” with many for-profit partners and enablers. Their website describes their endorsement of Social Impact Bonds and Pay for Success. As I look at Twitter now, I see terrific book titles for children and a lovely quote from Mister Rogers, whose upcoming movie I noted on Twitter yesterday.īut I have been informed that they have a dark side of their own. ![]() I originally noted that has lovely activities for children. One can find nice social-emotional learning (SEL) activities.īut now states are setting up SEL standards about what children should think and feel. Helping children behave and work with each other is second nature to teaching. Good teachers have always built social skills into their classes. Why would parents and teachers, tired of high-stakes testing in their public schools, wish to sign onto more assessment that tests, tracks, and profiles their child’s behavior online?
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |